While the Outlander mid-season finale was all about Frank Randall (played by the incomparable Tobias Menzies) – deservedly so for both male leads – the Part 2 season premiere, Episode #109: THE RECKONING, is all about James Fraser (Sam Heughan).

This episode sets the tone perfectly for the remainder of the season. A level of complexity is added to the storyline, overshadowing Claire’s (Caitriona Balfe) personal predicament. As we discover following Jamie throughout the halls of Castle Leoch and listening to his inner monologues, he leads a very complicated life – a conclusion Claire came to after knowing Jamie only a few days.

With the exception of the comical spanking scene, this episode is rather serious. It also feels dense in that several story elements are introduced or expanded upon – from Jamie’s rivalry with Randall, his relationship with Laoghaire, his role within the clan, and especially his marriage to Claire. It’s the first episode in the series I had to watch more than once to absorb it all.

It’s good to be back with a powerful new episode and a new Jamie’s Top 30 Looks, so let’s jump right in with . . .

#30: Jamie’s Taking One For The Team Face – It’s not like Jamie had any hope of using that part of his body tonight anyway . . .

#29: Jamie’s I Don’t Know What You Just Called Me But It Sounds Bad Face – So many times we’ve said, “Stop talking, Claire.” Not here. You go, girl!

#28: Jamie’s Marriage Sucks So Far Face – From sucky honeymoon straight into a miserable marriage . . .

#27: Jamie’s I’m Waiting For An Apology Face – Hmm. Looks like Jamie’s chin is giving Claire’s a little competition. Well, if there’s an online Best Chin Award somewhere, I’m sure the fans will start a campaign for it.

#26: Jamie’s I Haven’t Had A Bath In A Month Face – Umm . . . yeah. Who cares? No one’s kicking that face out of bed.

#25: Jamie’s Well, This Is Awkward Face – The only thing more awkward than hearing your uncle admit to doing his sister-in-law is running into your ex-girlfriend in a dark corridor.

#24: Jamie’s Well, This Is Even More Awkward Face – See.

#23: Jamie’s I Got As Good As I Gave Face – How did it feel sleeping on the floor, Jamie?


#22: Jamie’s F#@* You Dougal Face – You know I had to slip one in here.

#21: Jamie’s Laoghaire Is So Innocent Face – Give it a second . . .

#20: Jamie’s I’m Touching Laoghaire’s Breast Face – I said a second, not a whole damn minute . . .

#19: Jamie’s I Made A Vow And I’ll Not Break It Face – Yeah, that would sound more convincing, Jamie, if your hand wasn’t still on Laoghaire’s breast.

#18: Murtagh’s A Skelped Ass Never Did Anyone Any Permanent Damage Face – Hey, how’d this one get in here?

#17: Jamie’s It’ll Be The Last Thing You Ever See Face – Randall wants Jamie to take his shirt off. Come on! We all want Jamie to take his shirt off.

#16: Jamie’s I Can’t Believe I Have To Spank My Wife Face – We waited six months to find out what Jamie’s justification would be for spanking Claire. Turns out . . . he didn’t need any – other than several generations of wife-disciplining husbands.

#15: Jamie’s Why Did I Listen To Ned About The Firearms? Face – Why did you listen to Ned about your wedding night?

#14: Jamie’s Gotcha Face – This scene between Jamie and Randall is so deliciously wicked, I’m counting the seconds to their Wentworth showdown.

#13: Jamie’s What The F#@* Did I Do? Face – Jamie’s been home for ten lousy minutes and he’s already being blamed for the MacKenzie disunity and the Jacobite rebellion – not to mention that thing at Fort William and marrying a sassenach.

#12: Jamie’s She’s Not Going To Enjoy This But I Am Face – It occurs to me, Jamie is more of a virgin here than before his wedding night.

#11: Jamie’s Do I Want To Join You? Face – I have no idea what’s really being said here, but does it matter? Look at those cheekbones.

And here’s our first Top 10 of 2015:

#10: Jamie’s What’s Ghàidhlig for Consigliere? Face – A little pinch of Michael Corleone never hurts. After all, it’s not personal. It’s business. Don’t forget to take the cannoli.

#9: Jamie’s She’s Still Mad About My Spanking Her? Face – What’s it been? Six hours?

#8: Jamie’s If Ever My Hand Is Raised In Rebellion Face – Could the hilt of that dagger look any more like a penis? I don’t think so . . .

#7: Jamie’s Forgiven Face – This is my favorite moment in the entire episode. No joke.

#6: Jamie’s I Am A Man Face – No argument here.

#5: Jamie’s I Want You Face –  Can you turn this way when you say that, Jamie? And feel free to tack my name on the end.

#4: Jamie’s Will You Have Me?  Face – She’s half-naked, lad. What do you think?

#3: Jamie’s What’s F#@*ing? Face – Personally, I think it’s better to show you, Jamie, rather than tell you. Enforces proper usage of the word.

#2: Jamie’s I Am A Sadist Face – Sadist or not . . .  how can anyone stay mad at a  man with a face like this . . . and a body . . . and a voice?

#1: Claire’s Jamie Is Booping Me On The Nose Face – Aww. Jamie can boop me on the nose any day. Let’s face it . . . he can boop me anywhere he wants.


Outlander Episode #110: BY THE PRICKING OF MY FINGER premieres on Starz on Saturday, 11 April 2015 in the U.S.

If you missed the mid-season finale Jamie’s Top 30  Looks, you’ll find them here: Top 30 Looks from Outlander Episode #108: BOTH SIDES NOW

My in-depth recap of this episode is also available: A True Fan’s Review of Outlander Episode #109: THE RECKONING

40 thoughts on “Jamie’s Top 30 Looks from #Outlander Episode 109: THE RECKONING

  1. Ohh god youre just so funny Candida!!! love your top 30 posts….laugh so hard I cry. Thnx so much!

  2. Hi Candida! 🙆🏻 Ahh…at last. Another sign that Droughtlander is over — we have your Top 30…& they’re really good ones! 👍🏼 My personal 2 favorites are Claire’s chin and nose boop. The nose boop was an adorable addition to an already post-coital, lovely intimacy. 💏 Good to see you back!

  3. Delightful! Thank you so much Candida! I LOVE that this was a Jamie – centric episode, just wish the show editors had picked shots of Jamie on key lines instead of staying on Clare’s (admittedly beautiful and expressive) face, especially on “You are my home now”.
    Sorry, so much wonderful in this outstandingly scripted by the fab Matt Roberts epi- back to the fabulousness that is Candida!
    Look #10- YES! BRIL! This is the Jamie who is confidant of princes and generals, and Lords and Dukes and chiefs and men and Claire and Bree Roger Ian…. oops Too late to say Spoiler? 😉
    But Look #1 – no words… what you said 😀
    Bless you. PLEASE keep these coming.

    1. Thank you, Lori. Trying to finish my full recap before ep110 airs. Lol.

      Everyone’s thoughtful comments are greatly appreciated & keep me motivated!

  4. Not having your wonderful posts was almost as bad as not having Outlander itself during Droughtlander. So happy you’re back. This was such a good episode, REALLY good. Jamie and Claire went through every emotion in the catalog.

      1. Aww, with all your many followers, it’s so nice to know you thought of me. During Droughtlander, I kept up with many other blogs, communities and web sites so I was never far away. I took some time to read several other books on my to do list and am currently re-reading the part of Outlander that will be covered in the next eight episodes. Then, along with everyone else, I’ll be following the development and filming of DIA and probably be reading that book again.

        I suppose you follow Terry and read in her blog about Celtic Crofts, the company that’s been licensed to offer Outlander related products. I’m very much looking forward to the new tartans and hopefully some of Terry’s wonderful accessories.

        As I said before, so very glad you’re back. You’ve been sorely missed.

        1. I had not heard about Celtic Crofts. I’m very behind on my Outlander news. During the hiatus, I finished my first novel – very proud of it. Now I need to find someone who likes it as much as me. lol.

          I’d like to recommend the All Souls Trilogy by Deb Harkness if you haven’t already read it. The Outlander Podcast girls have started an AllSoulsPod to follow the development to be aired on BBC. We are all very excited to watch for the first signs of casting. Join us!

          1. Oh yes! I am already quite familiar with the All Souls Trilogy. I’ve read the first two books and “The Book of Life” is #1 (I already own it) on my summer reading list when “Outlander” is over. Where do I find he AllSoulsPodcast or the group? Any idea if this will be on BBC America as well as BBC in the UK?

  5. Yes! Was so excited for this and your recap! I love #1. Love, love, love it. My favorite Jamie face this episode was his “Gotcha” face and you can throw Murtagh in anytime you want. 🙂

    Side note: his eyes were so blue in the Horrocks scene!

  6. So glad that you are back. Droughtlander was awful enough without your wit and hilarity. The only look I didn’t like was the very last minute of the spanking face. Jamie kind of looked like a maniac!

  7. Oh Candida, I enjoyed this so much! Thank you 😉 Especially for pointing out that Jamie’s chin was giving Claire’s a run for the money!

  8. Thanks so much for these delicious posts. Looking forward to the rest of the season with great anticipation.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s